Menu

Paul Scholes verdict on solving Manchester United’s midfield dilemma

Paul Scholes has pinpointed where Manchester United are going wrong with team selections in most matches, and we really don’t think many fans will be in disagreement with it.

The former United midfielder, who came through the academy to achieve incredible success, thinks United’s lack of balance in midfield could cost Ole Gunnar Solskjaer the Premier League title in a season the manager will be looking to show process – three years in.

United have registered 14 points from a possible 21 in the Premier League but the manager has received lots of criticism in previous months for setting up with two holding midfielders in his preferred formation.

The defeat to Aston Villa and the 1-1 draw with Everton at Old Trafford last Sunday encouraged Scholes to speak out about it on the Webby and O’Neill show.

Watch the interview with Scholes below:

“You mention McTominay, I think he’s the best one for that role out of the four of them, I’d definitely go for him,” Scholes said, as quoted by the Metro.

“I think he’s got everything, he’s athletic, he can get around the pitch, he’s got great ability as well. He’s capable of sitting in that position.

“Ole doesn’t seem to be able to get the balance right in that team. Is he going to play that one with the rest around him, and have Pogba next to him who he probably doesn’t trust defensively? Or is he going to play two holding midfield players.

“That’s the difference between United and I think Liverpool and City – they are much more aggressive, more attack-minded.

“You think of City going away to Chelsea, they play one holding midfield player and almost play six or seven forward players – that’s the difference in mentality.

“I think if Ole can get that right with that balance in the team… going forward I don’t think is a problem. Going forward we’ve got so many exciting players with Cristiano coming.”

You’d have to say the football to date this season has been underwhelming.

We signed sheer quality in the summer and the performances haven’t improved, and if one midfielder was to sit in our midfield my choice would be McTominay over Nemanja Matic.

Something needs to change and the next few fixtures are going to be a real challenge.

We’re up against it – but that is a constant pressure as Manchester United manager.

More Stories Fred Manchester United Ole Gunnar Solskjaer Paul Pogba Paul Scholes Scott McTominay

One response to “Paul Scholes verdict on solving Manchester United’s midfield dilemma”

  1. Dr Andrew Limo says:

    The problem is not McTominay but the fact that we have an Infant Mgr OGS that is limited in experience at this level of football and even more so at United’s level and is clueless in developing and maximizing the superstar players that United has. The Board needs to make a serious decision about keeping him or replacing him….. because he WILL NEVER Win ANY Silverware and in fact i i predict that United will lose 6, win 2 and draw 2 in the first 10 games immediately after the international break.