Jamie Carragher called Lisandro Martínez’s criticism of Manchester United’s hierarchy awful, while Wayne Rooney said the defender had gone too far and disrespected his team-mates after the 2-0 defeat to Atlético Madrid.
Martínez used his post-match interview to question United’s summer recruitment and call for more from the club’s senior decision-makers. The reaction has turned the defender’s remarks into a dispute not only about squad investment, but also about where that conversation belongs.
The defeat in Madrid preceded United’s immediate response to Atlético, with the Reds finishing the match with 10 men.
Former players challenge Martínez’s timing
According to Sky Sports, Martínez said he had expected more from the club’s leadership in the transfer window and singled out technical director Jason Wilcox. He argued that United needed more players to compete and that scrutiny should extend beyond the manager and the squad.
United spent £155 million on four major summer signings after finishing third in the Premier League last season. Carragher argued that Martínez’s comments would dominate the discussion in the days ahead, and questioned the defender’s own start to the campaign.
Rooney also felt Martínez should have kept the criticism internal. He said the defender’s performances had not been good enough to justify the intervention, and that the remarks could be taken as a slight on the players alongside him.
🔴 Follow Stretty News on Google as a preferred source and be first with every United update.
| Match | Result | United players | Winless run |
| Atlético Madrid vs United | 2-0 | 10 | Five games |
Investment and internal accountability collide
The underlying argument is not simply whether United need more recruitment. Rooney acknowledged that the squad could use investment in attack and defence, even as he objected to Martínez making that case publicly. Carragher likewise argued that the intervention would not help the club, despite its potential appeal to supporters frustrated with the hierarchy.
Martínez had pointed to last season’s third-place finish as a reason to expect the squad to be strengthened for the new campaign. Carragher disputed that framing, citing United’s early exits from cup competitions and the dismissal of a manager last season.
United are now five matches without a win, increasing the pressure around the team as well as the post-match fallout. Michael Carrick’s response, as reported by Sky Sports, was that the issue was not for discussion at that moment.
That leaves two connected questions in the open: whether Martínez’s concerns about recruitment will be addressed within the club, and whether the criticism will remain a post-match flashpoint. Rooney’s position was clear on the route forward: any concerns should be handled through conversations between players, the manager and the board.
